A friend of the rising star told the New York Post about Pia's alleged new relationship: 'It seems inevitable to anyone with eyes'.
The 22-year-old Howard Beach native has not officially ended the relationship with Nunez but she has limited her conversations with him while she lives the high life in Hollywood.'They hadn't spoken as often as you'd think once she made the final 12', the source said.
He apparently even comforted her crying family at the Roma View catering hall that he manages while they watched the show.
The nation was shocked when American Idol stand-out Pia Toscano was eliminated from the show two weeks ago.
But in another shocking elimination it appears she has dumped her long-term boyfriend and traded up for the more famous Mark Ballas.
PHOTOS: Check out the latest pics of Jamie-Lynn Sigler Other stars spotted supporting the event included Kris Jenner, Kathy Griffin, Naya Rivera, Jo Anna Garcia, Emmanuelle Chriqui, Jessica Szohr, Pia Toscano, Nick Viall and fiancee Vanessa Grimaldi, along with Camilla Luddington – who is making her first public appearance after welcoming her daughter Hayden last month.
American Idol alum Pia Toscano is engaged to her boyfriend, Jimmy R. In the photo, Toscano shows off her massive new bling.